You can view a list of the awards that Tyler has been nominated for as well as the ones he has won below. This list includes separate icons to showcase nominations/wins.
- = win
- = nomination
2017
- Saturn Awards as Best Guest Performance on a Television Series for Supergirl
2014
- Teen Choice Award as Choice TV: Male Scene Stealer for Teen Wolf
2008
- Fright Meter Award as Best Supporting Actor for Solstice
2005
- Young Artist Award as Best Performance in a TV Series (Comedy or Drama) – Leading Young Actor for 7th Heaven
- Teen Choice Award as Choice TV Actor: Drama for 7th Heaven
2004
- Teen Choice Award as Choice Breakout TV Star – Male for 7th Heaven
2003
- Saturn Award as Best Performance by a Younger Actor for Road to Perdition
- Broadcast Film Critics Association Award as Best Young Actor/Actress for Road to Perdition
- Las Vegas Film Critics Society Award as Youth in Film for Road to Perdition
- Online Film & Television Association Award as Best Youth Performance for Road to Perdition
- Phoenix Film Critics Society Award as Best Performance by a Youth in a Leading or Supporting Role – Male for Road to Perdition
- Young Artist Award as Best Performance in a Feature Film – Leading Young Actor for Road to Perdition